The NIL Edge – April 11, 2025

Your Weekly Update on Name, Image, and Likeness Developments in College Sports.

Following the April 7, 2025 settlement hearing in $2.8 billion House v. NCAA matter, several key developments have emerged:

1. Judge Requests Further Clarifications Before Finalizing Settlement

U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken, while acknowledging the general soundness of the proposed settlement, has requested additional information on several issues before granting final approval. These include concerns about roster management, the methods used for NIL valuation, and potential impacts on smaller athletic programs. Judge Wilken emphasized the need for modifications to address these concerns adequately. https://apnews.com/article/nil-ncaa-house-settlement-5937493302218963fc678562dcc8d222

2. Athlete Objections Highlight Valuation Concerns

Prominent athletes, including LSU gymnast Olivia Dunne, have voiced objections to the proposed NIL valuation methods within the settlement. Dunne argued that the settlement undervalues athletes’ earning potentials and fails to account for established social media influence and brand demand prior to NIL legalization. She emphasized the need for accurate compensation that reflects true market value. https://www.the-sun.com/sport/13970371/olivia-dunne-clear-statement-lsu-gymnast-ncaa-settlement-case/

3. Legislative Advocacy by Power Four Conference Stakeholders

In parallel with the judicial proceedings, stakeholders from the Power Four conferences—the SEC, ACC, Big Ten, and Big 12—have been actively lobbying lawmakers on Capitol Hill. Their objectives include seeking antitrust protections, standardizing NIL regulations, and addressing athlete transfer rules. In our view, this issue is not getting the attention it deserves. https://apnews.com/article/ncaa-congress-nil-c5c72d4727a1c3b382c8737f910df3ed

4. JT Toppin’s Record-Breaking NIL Deal Influences NBA Draft Decision

Texas Tech basketball star JT Toppin has opted to return for his junior season, foregoing the 2025 NBA Draft. This decision was significantly influenced by an unprecedented NIL deal reportedly worth around $4 million, nearly doubling previous high-profile NIL agreements. Toppin’s case exemplifies how substantial NIL opportunities are impacting athletes’ career choices, potentially motivating them to remain in college rather than turning professional. https://www.sbnation.com/college-basketball/2025/4/9/24404732/jt-toppin-nil-money-nba-draft-bypass-texas-tech-biggest-payments

5. Nebraska Secures $300,000 NIL Package with Tournament Victory

The Nebraska Cornhuskers men’s basketball team clinched the inaugural College Basketball Crown by defeating UCF 77-66. This victory earned the team a $300,000 NIL package, while UCF received $100,000 as the runner-up. Such tournaments highlight the growing integration of NIL incentives in collegiate competitions. https://www.cbssports.com/college-basketball/news/college-basketball-crown-2025-nebraska-earns-300000-nil-package-with-win-vs-ucf-in-championship-game/

6. IRS Targets NIL Collectives for Compliance

The Internal Revenue Service has identified NIL collectives as a focus for compliance in 2025. With changes in the political landscape and adjustments to IRS funding, there is an increased emphasis on ensuring that NIL activities adhere to tax regulations. https://frontofficesports.com/irs-identifies-nil-collectives-2025-target/

7. Shifts in NIL Collectives Amid Legal Changes

The anticipated finalization of the House v. NCAA settlement is expected to permit universities to directly compensate student-athletes through revenue-sharing models. Will this be the end of the road for traditional NIL collectives? https://www.out2win.io/blog/the-shift-in-nil-collectives-power-4-colleges-reshape-athlete-support-for-2024-2025

Got a story tip or NIL question? Let’s talk.