Federal Executive Order Targets NIL Recruiting Abuses
Federal Executive Order Targets NIL Recruiting Abuses
The NIL world just got a major shakeup. On July 24, 2025, President Trump signed an executive order which purports to curb pay-for-play abuse, clarify athlete employment status, and preserve the integrity of college sports. https://www.whitehouse.gov/fact‑sheets/2025/07/fact‑sheet‑president‑donald‑j‑trump‑saves‑college‑sports
Whether you’re an athlete, advisor, collective, or school, this new federal move demands close attention and fast action. Here’s what you need to know.
Key Highlights
Third-party pay-for-play NIL deals banned
The executive order prohibits booster-driven NIL payments used explicitly as recruiting incentives. Acceptable: legitimate fair‑market endorsements from brands or businesses with a bona fide commercial interest.
👉 Source: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jul/24/trump-college-sports-executive-order-nil
Athletes’ employment status debated
The Department of Labor and NLRB are directed to clarify whether student-athletes are considered employees or amateurs, with guidance prioritizing educational benefits over employment rights.
Support for non-revenue and women’s sports
Schools with athletic revenue over $125 million must expand opportunities, while those earning at least $50 million must maintain current levels, aiming to prevent NIL-fueled disparity.
👉 Source: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jul/24/trump-college-sports-executive-order-nil
30-day federal enforcement push
Agencies like the DOE, FTC, and DOJ have 30 days to establish regulatory frameworks around NIL treatment and enforceable standards.
👉 Source: https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jul/24/trump-college-sports-executive-order-nil
National NIL policy framework
The order encourages harmonizing rules across all 30+ NIL state laws and supports limited antitrust exemptions sought by the NCAA through efforts like the SCORE Act.
👉 Sources:
https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jul/24/trump-college-sports-executive-order-nil
https://frontofficesports.com/president-trump-is-actively-working-on-an-nil-related-executive-order
Strategic Analysis for NIL Edge Audience
1. Deal Structures Need Re-evaluation
Athletes and collectives must ensure NIL agreements clearly serve business interests—not circumvent boosters as recruitment inducements. Transparency, documentation, and third-party substantiation are imperative.
2. Compliance Growth Opportunity
The College Sports Commission’s NIL Go portal and compliance mechanisms gain importance for vetting deals in line with fair-market standards. Expect heightened scrutiny and potential audits tied to the new federal guidelines.
👉 Sources:
https://frontofficesports.com/pro-ncaa-bill-passes-two-markups-in-path-to-house-floor
https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2025/jul/24/trump-college-sports-executive-order-nil
3. Labor Classification Risk vs. Opportunity
While the order aims to preserve amateur status, classification influence could shift toward employee protections, affecting benefits, contracts, and union rights. Stakeholders on both sides should monitor forthcoming NLRB/Labor rulings closely.
4. Collectives Face Revenue Threshold Obligations
Elite schools and their funded collectives may be compelled to redirect resources to non-revenue sports. Expect calls for value redistribution if revenue-sharing and NIL spending heavily favor marquee sports.
5. Congressional Bridge Needed
Many of the order’s goals—like antitrust protection and statutory amateurism—require the SCORE Act or similar legislation to solidify them. Key House bills are advancing but remain stalled in the Senate.
👉 Sources:
https://frontofficesports.com/pro-ncaa-bill-passes-two-markups-in-path-to-house-floor
https://frontofficesports.com/trump-signs-executive-order-on-college-sports
What to Watch Next
Will the NLRB or DoL clarify athlete status in favor of continued amateurism or define athletes as workers?
How will federal agencies enforce the 30-day directives and auditing capacities?
Can the SCORE Act or similar legislation pass both chambers, reinforcing the order’s intent?
Will schools adjust NIL budgets in response to federal requirements around non-revenue sports?
Reach out for more info! [email protected]
